| | As Time Goes By Ernest in Love | All Our Friends Rodgers and Hart | Fantasy Side By Side By Sondheim |
| | Celebrate! 2 Suite | Unsung Cole (and Classics, Too) Stagestruck | Reprise Perfectly Frank |
| | Kaleidoscope Some Enchanted Evening | Gotta Sing, Gotta Dance, 's Wonderful's, Marvelous, 's Gershwin | Red Hot and Cole Through the Years |
| | Crazy Rhythm Marvelous Melodies | Cavalcade Carefree | The Apple Tree Encore II |
| | The Mystery of Irma Vep All Night Strut | Million Dollar Medley Pizzazz | The Best of Everything Pump Boys and Dinettes |
| | The Taffetas Smoke on the Mountain | Schoolhouse Rock Live! Boulevard of Blues | Dracula, The Musical Blame it on the Movies |
| | Clue, The Musical Stardust | 2 By 5 Beehive | Smoke on the Mountain The Taffetas |
| | Sander's Family Christmas The Mystery of Irma Vep | The artistic staff of Carey Dinner Theatre chose to take the 2003 summer to explore other opportunities. | Pump Boys and Dinettes You're a Good Man Charlie Brown |
